[Archers] MiC Qualifications - was: Re: Ymir & Archery

[Siegfried]

I've been staying out of this thread, because I believe that others
(Janyn, Cog, Lorelei, Karl, etc) are saying everything well.

But I wanted to respond to this one side-point, which I disagree with:

> I also believe that if you are going to be MIC of an event, you need to
>  be versed in all the disciplines that are going to be there.

I will contend that point.  One doesn't not been to be well versed with
all the disciplines (though, it can certainly make things easier).   One
simply needs to be good at delegation, trust their warranted marshals
underneath of them, and support them.

We've had a strong tradition for a while up here in the North, of
having, say, a Thrown Weapons Marshal, be the MiC of a large event like
Highland River Melees - (Where there might not even be Thrown Weapons
happening!)

And those situations have often been the absolute best.   Because the
person would find deputies to run each of the activities, trust them to
do so, trust their decisions, and then in turn, simply help provide
oversight between all the activities (helping coordinate their
schedules), solve any site issues that are presented, help general
layout of the event taking the various marshals information into
account, clear any roadblocks, and support their marshals expertly.

While having no idea how Heavy combat, or Archery, or Rapier, is done.

And I don't see any issues with that at all :)

Siegfried

PS.  That being said, I certainly don't have a problem with having some
MiC training, that specifically drives that concept home.   I am
concerned however that adding a separate MiC training, at any more
effort than a single class & checkmark on your card.  Might harm events
more than help, as it would reduce the number of people who would MiC an
event.



-- 
Barun Siegfried Sebastian Faust, OP - Baron Highland Foorde - Atlantia
http://hf.atlantia.sca.org/ - http://crossbows.biz/ - http://eliw.com/