[MR] Wikipedia: Mournauer Portrait
Garth Groff via Atlantia
atlantia at seahorse.atlantia.sca.org
Sun Jun 5 03:53:28 PDT 2016
Noble Friends,
Today one of Wikipedia's featured articles concerns the portrait of
Alexander Mornauer in the National Gallery in London. It seems this
painting was altered in the 1700s and passed off as a Hans Holbein
portrait of Martin Luther. While this mis-identification, or outright
fraud, is out of our period, it is still fascinating. The painting is
actually by someone other than Holbein, and does date to the late 1400s.
It seems amazing how it could be passed off as Luther when the letter
clearly gives the subject's name, but its various owners probably saw
only what they wanted to see:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master_of_the_Mornauer_Portrait .
There is a lot we can learn from this portrait. First the letter in the
man's hand. No stamps, of course, but consider how the paper or
parchment is folded and addressed. No doubt it was sealed on the
reverse. The signet ring is an absolute delight, with the image of the
moor being a cant on the owner's name. Obviously the clothing would be
of interest to anyone doing a mid-to-late 15th century German persona.
It is trimmed in fur, the lacing loops at the throat are cast as a
single ornate piece, and those elaborate round objects (buttons) are
eye-catching. And how about that hat in the restored version? I wouldn't
be caught dead in it, but that hat is worthy of study and duplication.
Also of interest are the other three portraits shown at the end of the
article, thought to be by the same artist. All the hats are different,
and give us a mini-gallery of German head wear of that time. These
portraits are worthy of blowing up for further study (click on the
portraits to see larger versions, then click again for even larger sizes).
"Pius Joachim" offers much of interest. Particularly note the bowless
spectacles shown in the upper right corner. There is also a packet of
letters, one still sealed. Not surprisingly for a pious man, the subject
is telling his rosary. The red beads are probably stone, possibly
carnelian which is found in Germany. Joachim has his left eyebrow raised
a bit making his visage much more lifelike, but his eyes don't seem to
match the plane of his face upon close study, giving him an odd,
disjointed appearance. It was not unusual for 15th century artists to
make their subjects a bit more noble or interesting looking by moving
features around a bit or reshaping a jaw for emphasis. Rogier van der
Weyden was notorious for this, and apparently appreciated for it since
he remained court painter to Duke of Burgundy Philip the Good for many
years. His 1460 "Portrait of a Lady" shows this in the unnatural
positioning of the subject's ear and a backward extension of her skull,
both of which enhance her attractiveness until you look closely and see
that everything looks unnatural:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogier_van_der_Weyden#/media/File:Rogier_van_der_Weyden_-_Portrait_of_a_Lady_-_Google_Art_Project.jpg
.
The middle figure also has much to tell us. Fuzzy hat, with a cloth
band. His gown is trimmed in fur. The sleeves at the wrist appear to
have beaded detail, and his right wrist shows the sleeve is laced on the
underside and a part of his shirt shows behind the lacing. There are
metal lacing loops at his collar that are unused. He is also telling his
beads, which again appear to be carnelian. There is a marked similarity
of the face to Pius Joachim, but this might just be the style of the
artist.
The third figure has less detail. Could this be a minor clerk of some
sort, or perhaps a lawyer? Note the bands at his collar, similar to
those traditionally worn by English barristers.
Yours Aye,
Lord Mungo Napier, That Crazy Scot
More information about the Atlantia
mailing list